Len Brown?s legagy: Sexy Times or Trains?

What will Len Brown’s legacy be?

“It’s been a helluva journey.”

In five words, Len Brown’s deputy Penny Hulse captured his six years as the first mayor of the amalgamated Auckland.

Mr Brown leaves the office with a legacy that will not be fully appreciated until the 2023 opening of the City Rail Link project which he championed.

The 3.4km twin-rail tunnels will cost around $3 billion, and took Mr Brown nearly three years to help convince the government to move from public scorn, in 2010, to Prime Ministerial agreement, in 2012, to co-fund the project.

The tunnels will create a loop under the CBD, boosting the frequency and capacity of the rail network, and are expected to trigger large commercial property developments along its route. ?

Work has begun, and completion will be testament to Mr Brown’s commitment to making a change as transformative as the amalgamation of Auckland’s eight local bodies, which brought him to office in 2010.

“That should be your legacy alone, you made that happen, and history needs to record that,” Ms Hulse told the final council meeting last week.

Also on the ‘done’ list for Mr Brown’s two terms was co-shepherding the biggest planning exercise undertaken in this country, the Unitary Plan which will bring higher density housing to more of the city.

Another milestone yet to be fully tested is the agreement with the government on the direction and funding of major transport projects in coming decades – again an unprecedented step in long-term city development.

That legacy is actually one of massive debt and huge rates increases…all for a dud train set.

But Mr Brown’s incumbency also had a flipside which tainted his second term in office, and ultimately made him unelectable in 2016.

Three days after re-election in 2013, Mr Brown publicly admitted a two-year extramarital affair with Bevan Chuang, a member of a council advisory panel.

Mr Brown dismissed calls for his resignation, but angry councillors demanded an inquiry into whether the affair had involved ratepayer’s money.

Some $238,000 was spent on a report by consultants EY, which found no inappropriate use of council resources, but that Mr Brown and his family had enjoyed hotel rooms and upgrades valued at $39,000.

The mayor faced the humiliation of having to pay $40,000 towards the consultants’ cost.

The episode cost the mayor significant public support, and during the second-term, councillors once loyal turned privately hostile.

Ms Hulse, in her tribute speech, noted that public loyalty to Mr Brown had come at a cost to some councillors.

“Some of those have had to burn off some degree of political support by being seen to politically support you.”

Yep, just like Colin Craig’s supporters…sticking in despite all the evidence to the contrary.

Good riddance Len, you should have gone in 2013. Now bugger off and don’t come back.


– Radio NZ